Woman Arrested at Penfield School District Office After Attempting to Confront Superintendent Over False Rumor

A woman was arrested Tuesday morning after attempting to forcibly enter the Penfield Central School District office to confront the superintendent over a false online rumor, authorities and district officials said.

Dr. Tasha Potter was appointed as Penfield Central School District Superintendent Sep. 1, 2024

According to a letter sent to families by Superintendent Dr. Tasha Potter, the individual showed up at the district office with the intent to confront her over misinformation circulating online that she planned to leave the district. Dr. Potter was en route to the building when she was informed of the situation and advised not to enter.

District officials say the woman’s behavior escalated quickly. She became physically aggressive and pushed a staff member. Security personnel from Blackhawk Security responded promptly, de-escalated the situation, and contacted the Monroe County Sheriff’s Office.

According to the Sheriff’s Office, Stacey Decker was arrested at the scene and issued an appearance ticket for harassment.

“Our front office staff responded calmly and professionally,” Potter wrote in her message to parents. “This situation is a strong reminder of why our layered safety system, District staff, security partners, and law enforcement are so important.”

The district has since reinforced safety protocols across all school buildings, the superintendent said.

In the letter, Dr. Potter directly addressed the rumor at the center of the incident, stating: “I am not leaving the Penfield Central School District. I remain fully committed to this District and deeply proud to serve this community.”

The incident comes amid heightened tensions in the district in recent months, following controversy over the inclusion of the children's book "The Rainbow Parade" in an elementary school library. The book, which depicts a young girl's experience at a Pride parade, sparked heated debates at a February school board meeting, leading to a series of threats directed at district officials and the cancellation of March board meetings.

In response to the threats, the district implemented heightened security measures for board meetings, including the use of metal detectors and the presence of security personnel.

The district emphasized its continued commitment to the safety and well-being of students, staff, and families. Anyone with questions or concerns is encouraged to contact the superintendent’s office or their school principal.